Exploring the 'What If?' Zone

A peek at some of our newest moonshot investigations, and tips for unleashing creativity

Astro Teller, Captain of Moonshots/November 19, 2026

What if we could harvest electricity from lightning? What if we replaced mining with mushrooms? What if we grew most of our crops underwater?

These are just a few of the out-there questions our guests posed last month at Xchange, a first-of-its-kind gathering we hosted at The Moonshot Factory. Over two days, scientists, technologists, and creatives dove into brainstorms, workshops, and prototyping sessions on the future of energy, food, science, ocean health, robotics, materials discovery, education, and more.

We also gave guests a first look at some of the big “what if?” questions our teams are currently exploring in agriculture, medicine, and health. For example:

  • What if we could grow food anywhere on Earth, regardless of soil quality or water scarcity? Desertification, water scarcity, climate volatility, and pathogens are threatening soil-based agriculture and global food security. Could a nutrient-rich fog environment be the answer to growing crops efficiently, everywhere?

  • What if you knew exactly how your body would respond to a new medicine and which therapies would work best for you? Clinical trials are slow and expensive, and 90% of the drugs tested in them fail. Could AI and organoid digital twins make trials faster and better — accelerating the development of more effective treatments for everyone?

  • What if we could move away from treating symptoms and deliver proactive care instead? Billions suffer from poorly managed endocrine dysfunction due to a lack of real-time hormonal visibility. Could a wearable sensor provide real-time monitoring of the endocrine system to optimize our understanding of health and aging?

We explore dozens of ideas like this each year, and fewer than 5% survive, so there’s no telling which of these will make it. But they fuel our optimism that solutions to the world’s most intractable problems are within reach.

Some of our early stage moonshots.

Tips for Getting Into the 'What If?' Zone

At X, we spend a lot of time in the “what if?” zone. But for people who don’t spend their days discussing space elevators or how to harness energy from glow worms, it can be tough to quiet the inner voice that worries about saying something “silly” or “wrong.” To help our guests let their wild ideas run free, we introduced them to some of the moonshot-thinking techniques we use at X—and we’re sharing them here, too, so everyone can fuel their next breakthrough.

Run a 'Bad Idea' Brainstorm

In sessions on the future of work, ocean health, education, and more, we ran “bad idea” brainstorms, where the goal was to come up with terrible ideas for solving pressing global problems. Our Rapid Evaluation team often uses this technique to limber up their creative muscles as they explore radical solutions. Asking for your worst ideas sidesteps the mental seize-up that can happen when you’re expected to be brilliant. Playfulness is the raw material of creativity, and more often than not, when you’re trying to be terrible on purpose, someone will stop you and say, “Hold on, you’re on to something.” To run your own bad idea brainstorm, try our online Moonshots Game.

Try Sketching Blind

Shane Washburn, an industrial designer in our Design Kitchen team, hosted a hands-on workshop on sketching for brainstorms. Many of us stopped drawing as kids and now shy away from the whiteboard because we think our drawings look “bad.” But as Shane explains, there are no bad sketches in brainstorms.

Here are his tips for getting started:

  • Remove anxiety by sketching blind: Put your drawing hand inside a cardboard box and look only at what you’re drawing. The results will be rough, but it’s fun, and it instantly silences your inner critic.

  • Find the essence: Look for one simple detail that captures the spirit of what you’re trying to convey. A buckle can turn a person in a hat into a pilgrim; a few lines under a backpack can turn it into a jetpack.

  • Keep your sketches rough to invite collaboration: Rough sketches are perfect for brainstorms because the ideas you’re discussing are just emerging, too. One person’s sketch can spark totally different ideas in someone else, and misinterpretations often lead the group down interesting rabbit holes. People are also far more likely to draw over and build on a rough sketch than on a polished drawing they think you’re attached to.

Prototype It

We have a saying at X: one prototype will save you 100 meetings. Instead of talking in circles about an idea that everyone imagines differently, show people something they can see and touch — even if it’s janky — and they’ll engage with it far more easily. In an Xchange session brainstorming solutions for workplace injuries, teams prototyped a sensor-equipped back brace to monitor posture and an AI tool to identify the most-reported workplace injuries by industry and location.

Prototyping doesn’t require special skills; a prototype just needs to help you learn something or answer a question. A spreadsheet, a document, or a vibe-coded app counts just as much as a rough piece of hardware. For more tips on how to get started prototyping, check out the guide from our Design Kitchen lead, Joe Sargent.

Ask 'How Startable is This?' — Not 'How Doable is It?'

In our science fiction–themed session, I asked the group to share their favorite futuristic inventions from movies, books, video games, comics, and more. Once we had our ideas on the whiteboard (think the medbay from Star Trek or learning by upload à la The Matrix), we rated each idea in two ways: How badly do you want to see this moonshot out in the world? And how startable is it?

We didn’t ask whether an idea was possible or likely to succeed, but whether it was plausible to attempt a first prototype — and whether that attempt might crack a meaningful piece of the problem. Technology is advancing so fast that the impossible today might be possible in a few years. And if you start now, technology might just catch up with you. For example, on a scale from 1 to 10, many people would rate the medbay a 1 or 2 if you ask how “doable” it is, yet rate it a 5 or 6 if you ask how “startable” it is.

It was energizing to spend time with people who believe as strongly as we do that technology is one of our powerful levers for tackling global challenges. I'm grateful to every guest who brought their hard problems, half-baked ideas, and big questions to the table.

If you’d like more tips for unleashing your creativity, or to learn how X’s inventors and creators turn "what if" into what's next, sign up for the Moonshot Newsletter or check out The Moonshot Podcast.